How’d it end up there?

Al Jazeera claims to have in its possession an Israeli government paper detailing the basic requirements Israel sees preconditions for any peace negotiations with the Palestinians.  I haven’t thought at all in depth about what these conditions are alleged to be, so I won’t comment on them here.  Instead, I wanted to blog briefly about something that popped into my head the moment I read the first paragraph:

Al Jazeera has obtained a document claiming to be Israel’s terms on which final status negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians can begin.

My question is, how do we know that this document is what it purports to be?   I can think instantly of four different factual narratives leading to that first paragraph:

1.  It’s a legitimate, albeit confidential internal Israeli document that was carelessly left lying around, which is how it ended in Al Jazeera’s hands.

2.  It’s a legitimate, albeit confidential Israeli document shared with Abbas, which Abbas’ political friends or enemies released, either to help or embarrass him.

3. It’s a legitimate, albeit confidential internal Israeli document that was deliberately leaked to Al Jazeera as a way of raising the flag and seeing if anyone salutes.

4.  It’s a phony document that the Israeli’s planted, again to raise the flag and see if anyone salutes.  That is, it really isn’t the Israeli bottom line, but Israel wants to see what the response will be.

5.  It’s a completely phony document, cooked up by Al Jazeera, Palestinians, or any one else with a dog in the fight that’s intended to narrow the parameters within which Israel will be forced to negotiate.

I’m sure you can come up with other scenarios.  All of them demonstrate that context matters.  Knowing whether the document is what it purports to be, and understanding how it ended up in Al Jazeera’s hands, are facts hugely helpful in interpreting both the document and subsequent responses to the document.  The only problem is that, if the true story is either option 3 or 4, any benefits to be gained from releasing such a document are destroyed if the underlying machinations behind its release are exposed.

3 Responses

  1. […] [Discuss This Topic With Bookworm] Share Article Al Jazeera, Israeli government, Palestinians    Sphere: Related Content | Trackback URL […]

  2. Forgive me being so anal, but dare I point out that you actually show 5 narratives instead of 4?

    Here is #6 – It’s a legitimate, albeit confidential Israeli document but somehow or other (a mole/spy?) Al Jazeera got their hands on it they don’t see the value in leaving the mole in place for the future.

  3. “Any benefits to be gained from releasing such a document are destroyed if the underlying machinations behind its release are exposed.”

    Exactly why much diplomacy occurs in secret. The exposure of the document can invalidate both it and the preconditions that allowed it to be written. Supposing even that it were a legitimate document and not a fake.

    Consider that the U.S. Constitution would never have been created had the deliberations of the Constitutional Congress been reported on throughout that one summer, much less, ahem, televised.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: